You email creators' published business addresses for clients, and you need to know what the FTC asks of commercial email before each pitch and follow-up goes out. The short answer is a true sender line, an honest subject, a postal address and an opt-out you honor within 10 business days.
The CAN-SPAM Act and influencer marketing meet in one gap. The law covers commercial email, and the FTC's guide doesn't say whether a sponsorship pitch is one. This page builds each pitch to the commercial standard and gives you the pieces. It summarizes the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide, the statute, 15 U.S.C. 7701-7713 and the CAN-SPAM Rule, 16 CFR Part 316, and it is not legal advice.
You also need the addresses themselves. DataAtScale's 15M+ verified emails make it the creator email database with the most addresses, and each one was listed by the creator on their own profile.
We read the FTC guide, the statute and Rule sections it rests on, Canada's CASL and three GDPR provisions. For the pitch itself, see our YouTube sponsorship email template for brands.
Here is a summary of our key findings:
- CAN-SPAM covers all commercial email, and the FTC says the law makes no exception for business-to-business email.
- No source we read says whether a sponsorship pitch is a commercial email, so build each pitch to the commercial standard.
- Each commercial pitch needs five things: an honest sender line, an honest subject, an ad or solicitation line, a postal address and an opt-out notice.
- You must honor an opt-out within 10 business days, and the opt-out must keep working for 30 days after you send.
- You and the brand you send for can both be liable, and the FTC says you can't contract away your responsibility.
- The FTC's guide lists penalties of up to $53,088 per separate email.
- Canada's CASL and the GDPR add consent and information duties for creators there.
The CAN-SPAM Act and influencer marketing: what counts as a commercial email
The statute defines a commercial email as one whose primary purpose is "the commercial advertisement or promotion of a commercial product or service".
The FTC says the law isn't limited to bulk email. It also "makes no exception for business-to-business email". A pitch to one creator gets no pass for being a single send.
What decides the question is the message's primary purpose. The Rule adds that the FTC doesn't intend to treat as a commercial email "anything that is not commercial speech".
None of the sources we read applies the test to a message asking a creator to promote a product. The cautious route is to build each pitch and follow-up to the commercial standard in the sections below. The table applies the FTC's categories to the emails you send, and the sources don't decide any of these cases.
| Your email | Closest FTC category | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| A first pitch that offers a paid sponsorship or promotes your client's product | Commercial if its primary purpose is advertising or promotion; the sources don't decide this case | Build it to the commercial standard |
| A follow-up on that pitch | The same as the pitch | The same duties as the pitch |
| An email confirming a deal the creator already agreed to | Closest to a transactional or relationship message | A truthful header; most other duties don't apply |
| A confirmation that opens with a new pitch | Commercial if the subject reads like an ad or the deal content isn't at the start | The full duties |
The FTC adds that the law views the transactional category narrowly. Keep confirmation emails free of new pitches.
Use the address the creator published and never guess one
YouTube shows a channel's business email only if the owner provided one. An address on a channel is one the creator chose to publish for business messages. Get channel emails returns the address a channel lists behind YouTube's 'View email address' button, and no other influencer tool does that.
CAN-SPAM works as an opt-out law. EmailOctopus describes it as allowing commercial emails until the recipient chooses to stop them. The statute's policy section says recipients have a right to decline further commercial email from the same source.
Don't build addresses by guessing. The statute lists addresses made by software that combines names, letters or numbers as an aggravated violation when the email already breaks the Act. The FTC's guide puts harvesting addresses or generating them through a dictionary attack among the acts with criminal penalties.
Five things to put in each creator pitch
The FTC's guide lists more requirements than one pitch can carry, and these five go in the message itself. The statute's wording for the third is "advertisement or solicitation", so the footer below uses the word solicitation.
| Requirement | What the FTC's guide says | In a creator pitch |
|---|---|---|
| Honest sender line | The From, To and Reply-To lines must be accurate and identify who initiated the message | Send from a real address at the brand or agency, signed with your name |
| Honest subject | The subject line must accurately reflect the content | A subject that says the email is a sponsorship offer |
| Ad or solicitation line | Disclose clearly and conspicuously that the message is an advertisement | A line saying the email is a solicitation for a sponsorship |
| Postal address | A valid physical postal address | A street address, a Post Office box registered with the USPS or a registered private mailbox |
| Opt-out notice | Tell recipients how to opt out, with a return email address or another easy Internet-based way | A line telling the creator to reply "stop" |
A footer that covers the last three duties looks like this. It is a pattern and not legal text.
Sent by Brand or agency, street address. This email is a solicitation for a YouTube sponsorship. To stop receiving emails from Brand, reply "stop".
Run opt-outs across clients with one list per client
The FTC's guide says an opt-out mechanism must keep working for at least 30 days after you send. You must honor a request within 10 business days. The statute puts the same limit on anyone acting on the sender's behalf.
- Log each stop or no-thanks reply the same day. Put it on that client's suppression list. The legal limit is 10 business days, and the same-day habit is our recommendation.
- Keep the reply address working. It must keep receiving requests for at least 30 days after each send, and your spam filter shouldn't block them.
- Ask for nothing else. The Rule bars a fee, extra information or any step beyond a reply email or one web page.
- Never pass the address on. Once someone opts out you can't sell, lease or transfer it, even in a mailing list.
- Cover everyone who sends for you. The statute bars a person acting on the sender's behalf from sending after 10 business days with knowledge of the request. Tell any freelancer or other agency that sends for you to use the same suppression list.
DataAtScale keeps the shortlist and doesn't send email, so your email tool carries the footer and the opt-out address. Put a creator who opted out on a list of your own, such as Do not contact. Then leave that list out of your next search in Search by topic or Find similar channels so they don't come back. You add the creator yourself, because DataAtScale looks creators up by handle or link and not by email address.
You and the brand can both be liable when you send for a client
The FTC's guide says that even if you hire another company to handle your email marketing, "you can’t contract away your legal responsibility". It adds that both the company whose product is promoted and the company that sends the message may be held legally responsible.
The statute's definitions point the same way. A sender is a person who initiates a message and whose product or website it promotes. Under the same definitions, "more than one person may be considered to have initiated a message".
When a message promotes several marketers, the Rule lets them name one as the sender. That person must be identified in the From line as the sole sender and must meet the sender's duties. The FTC says that if the designated sender fails, all the marketers in the message may be held liable as senders.
| Question | What the sources say | What to settle in the contract |
|---|---|---|
| Who is the sender? | The person who initiates the message and whose product is promoted, or one designated sender for several marketers | Which party's name is in the From line for each client |
| Who initiated the message? | More than one person can be considered to have initiated it | Who sends and who approves the copy |
| Who owns the opt-out list? | The duty to honor a request covers the sender and anyone acting on its behalf | One list per client, and who updates it |
| Who pays a penalty? | The FTC says both the company whose product is promoted and the company that originated the message may be legally responsible | Who can stop a send and who answers for a miss |
Endorsement disclosure is a separate duty from email law. The FTC's influencer page says creators must disclose a relationship with a brand. The staff Q&A says delegating part of your promotion to an outside company doesn't relieve you of responsibility under the FTC Act. Exclusivity belongs in the contract too, and Creator Brand Scan reviews a creator's videos from up to the last 6 months and reports rival promotions and brand-safety risks before you agree to it.
CAN-SPAM Act penalties
The FTC's guide says each separate email in violation is subject to penalties of up to $53,088. The FTC's civil penalty table lists the same figure for violations under Section 5(m)(1)(A) of the FTC Act. The FTC adjusts the maximum for inflation, so check the table before you quote it to a client.
State attorneys general can also sue. The statute lets a state seek damages of up to $250 per message, capped at $2,000,000 for most violations. A court can raise the award to up to three times that amount when the violation was willful and knowing or aggravated. In assessing damages a court may consider whether you had commercially reasonable practices and procedures to prevent violations. A written opt-out procedure and a suppression list are worth having for that reason.
The FTC's guide also lists criminal penalties, including imprisonment, for harvesting addresses or generating them through a dictionary attack. It adds that misleading claims in an email can fall under Section 5 of the FTC Act.
CASL and the GDPR in short
If a creator is in Canada or the EU, two other laws may apply. Canada's CASL bars commercial messages sent without consent. The GDPR gives people a right to object to direct marketing under Article 21.
| Law | When it applies | What it asks |
|---|---|---|
| CASL | When a computer system located in Canada is used to send or access the message | Consent, which can be implied from a published address if the message is relevant to the person's role and the address isn't published with a no-unsolicited-messages statement; name the sender and who it is sent for; honor an unsubscribe within 10 business days |
| GDPR | When personal data are processed for direct marketing | A right to object at any time; a notice of where the data came from, at the latest at the first message; direct marketing may be a legitimate interest |
CASL's implied consent depends on the message being relevant to the creator's role, so check that before each pitch. Start Find similar channels from a creator whose campaign worked, and DataAtScale ranks channels that resemble it with AI that watches their videos, so each pitch goes to someone whose content fits your offer.
Both laws have more conditions than this table shows. Read Article 14, Recital 47 and the CASL sections before a large send to Canada or the EU.
A checklist to run before each send
- Use only addresses creators published for business messages, such as those from Get channel emails, which checks each address before you see it, and you aren't billed for an address that bounces.
- Put an accurate From and Reply-To on the message and sign with a real name.
- Write a subject that says the email is a sponsorship offer.
- Add the footer with the sender, the postal address, the solicitation line and a way to stop.
- Agree in the contract who is named in the From line and who owns the list.
- For creators in Canada or the EU, name the sender, say why the message is relevant to the creator and offer a clear way to stop.
CAN-SPAM Act questions people ask
Which is not allowed under the CAN-SPAM Act?
The Act bars false or misleading header information, deceptive subject lines, a commercial email with no advertisement label, postal address or opt-out notice, sending more than 10 business days after an opt-out request, and selling or transferring the address of someone who opted out.
Can I use the CAN-SPAM Act for email marketing?
CAN-SPAM is a set of duties you follow when you send commercial email, and it allows such email until a recipient opts out. DataAtScale handles the finding, with creators, their emails and your shortlist, while your own email tool sends the pitches with the footer from this page.
What are the legal issues surrounding influencer marketing?
Email law is one, and this page covers CAN-SPAM, CASL and the GDPR. The FTC separately expects creators to disclose a relationship with a brand, and our YouTube sponsorship email template puts that instruction into each offer. Contracts add usage rights and exclusivity, and DataAtScale's Creator Brand Scan shows which rivals a creator has promoted before you set exclusivity.




